Monday, August 24, 2015

A radio astronomer goes to Mars... or, Las Campanas Observatories


Coming up the mountain and passing the sign to La Silla seems a bit like traversing to a different planet, so foreign is the landscape around Las Campanas Observatory in the high desert of Chile. Barely do we have enough time to put our suitcases in our rooms before we rush to dinner, which is renowned as some of the best Observatory food around. They did not lie with this boast, the dinner is braised pork with potatoes, beets, and fresh avocado. I’d say this is a new experience for this radio astronomer, but in truth, the food at Owens Valley Radio Observatory is also exceptional. I find Ramesh, the preceding observer to my shift to make arrangements to shadow him. He’s obliging, and so Diane (the undergraduate who is accompanying me on this virgin observing run) and I follow him up the mountain. Sadly, the sky has clouds that night, but we see how to take flats, take calibration spectra, and set up our observations. We thank him and head down early, aware that 1 day from now there will be no heading down early.

The next day, I am nervous. At lunch I plot over and over in my head how the observing schedule needs to be run. What have I missed? Wait, those are empanadas. Many people have told me about the empanadas. And they live up to their expectations. I ask for two for my night lunch. One to savor tonight, and one to savor tomorrow. Diane and I arrive at the telescope just before the sun sets. I run a practice arc lamp observation, and decide to do flats in the morning. Wise move? Depends on if my prediction that my California jet lag is actually beneficial. 7am feeling like 3am seems like it would work to my benefit in terms of night time fatigue.

It becomes clear that my lessons the previous day are not the complete set of instructions I need to run the telescope, but we start. A near-IR expert on Skype with me. Then the earth under our feet starts shaking - the telescope operator knows before we do from the jiggling in the pointing of the telescope. I head toward the heavy desk in case I need to jump under it - yes, it was that big. Magnitude 6.0. Biggest earthquake this Californian has been in, and the Chileans eat 6.0s for breakfast. That is when the internet goes out, having been taken out by the earthquake. So much for my near-IR expert on Skype. No crutches for me - time to dive headfirst into the deep end.

Post-earthquake is also when the GUIs start misbehaving. At first, I think this is due to my own inexperience. The instrument scientist is called up, he comes, and it becomes clear that it is not my ignorance, but likely a cable that got jiggled in congress with the mountain. Instrument scientist and observer go and check it out, “turn it off then back on again,” and we start anew, this time I have an expert making sure that I am running things properly (word to the wise: go up in the afternoon before your run. People might not tell you to, but I am. Seriously. Do that. Don’t be like me.) Things start running smoothly, and we get a rhythm. Diane, having weathered her first (and second!) earthquake runs things like a champ, though we release her from observing a little early since her cough seems to be getting worse, and sleep is the best cure for a cold.

As I write this, it is 4:47am. A half hour ago the moon set and we got to sneak outside during a 15min integration to stare at the stars. I saw the Magellanic clouds, as well as a meteor or two. Dark sites are pretty spectacular things. We are observing the last source of my night right now, working our way to the daylight, when I will observe some twilight flats and then head down the mountain, ready to observe first thing tomorrow evening. The moon is getting fuller, but I am no longer a rookie, having scaled the learning curve without internet and with the earth shaking beneath my feet.

Friday, August 7, 2015

Calling the Night

This is my first post on this blog, and it's a bit of a shame because tonight will not be a good night for astronomy from Las Campanas.  Exhibit A, the sunset this evening:


Last night was my first night "observing" on this run. I am the PI for three nights on Baade, hoping to find some unique high-redshift galaxies to study. I put "observing" in quotes because in reality we did not open the dome. There was a brief moment of hope. The clouds looked like they were parting! But then the wind picked up. (If the wind speed is higher than 35 miles per hour, we can't open the dome because the wind could damage the telescope.) So the telescope remained shuttered and no data was collected. Well, unless you count this lovely photo of the Belles of Campanas standing on the Nasmyth platform of the Baade Telescope. 

From the left: myself, Johanna, Angelica, and Cindy

Since there is no observing going on again tonight, I thought I'd write a post about Calling the Night... This is one of the most agonizing decisions a PI at the telescope must make. At one point during a terribly hopeless bought of bad weather you say to yourself and those with you at the telescope: "Ok, we are done. I call the night. We can all go to sleep." For most of us, we stay up all night hoping and hoping that the skies will clear, that the wind will die down, or that the humidity will drop. Observers all care very deeply for the telescopes they use, and so we remain patient and understanding about the fact that the telescope remains closed - but many of us still hold out hope. You see, we plan - sometimes for weeks - for a few nights on the telescope. We make target lists, calculate optimal observing strategies and exposure times. But in the end, Nature decides. 

Last night, I called it at 5AM. The wind was above 35 mph, and one must wait for the wind to stay below that mark for a full 30 minutes before the telescope can be opened. Twilight begins around 6AM, and while I can observe for a while after twilight begins, obtaining less than an hour of data is unfortunately not very useful for my current project. But trust me, it's an agonizing decision. Last night, I made the right call. There was no way we could have opened. 

Sadly, it's a decision I expect to make again tonight. The weather does not look good. 
We are currently suffering from an extreme winter storm that is expected to last well past the end of my run and drop a tremendous amount of snow in the Andes south of here. Right now, as you can see we have 50 mph winds. You can feel the wind shake the telescope building from time to time. It's kind of gloomy. 

I've called nights before. Last year, I was at Magellan for the 4th of July. It snowed. 



When there is snow on the dome, you call the night. Even if it stops snowing, the snow on the dome can melt and drip onto the telescope - or blow off the dome and onto the telescope. That's an easier decision - there is no chance for the night once there is snow on the dome. 

I'm here until Tuesday - I'm hoping before I leave we get to collect some interesting photons. But you never know - Nature decides. 


Thursday, August 6, 2015

First Observations

Visiting Las Campanas in winter means that weather somewhat occasionally does not cooperate with observational astronomy.  This storm that we're experiencing the last few days has been particularly harsh and unusual.
The clouds are low, the wind is strong, and we keep getting suckered by seeing clear skies at the edge of the cloud deck.
I planned for 8 nights at LCO expecting that at the worst about half would be a loss due to weather.  We saw some stars for an hour or two on my first night, and not a thing since.  Unlike the rays of sunshine in the photo above there's no good weather news on the horizon.  Despite this, we've been keeping busy with regular work and taking advantage of other things LCO has to offer.

Instead of stars, galaxies and planets, I have other observations for you:

Observation #1:  Astronomers are weather bugs.

The last four nights have been spent in part staring at our weather monitors, and trying to guess if there will be a break in the clouds between the multicolored bands coming in off the coast.

Observation #2: The viscachas know what's up.

Warm furry coat, hiding from the wind, protected under the eaves, and facing the sunset. 

Observation #3: Clouds are bad for observational astronomy, but utterly stunning for sunsets in the Atacama.

When I saw this sight out the window of my room, I dropped my toothbrush, grabbed my camera and ran to capture the sight.

Observation #4:  There is still plenty to do to keep ourselves busy productive members of the Observatory.


Views: Magellan Clay Telescope by Cynthia Hunt
Click and drag the photosphere above to explore inside the Magellan Clay Telescope!

The most important observation of the last four nights is that the LCO Telescope Operators are golden. They are incredibly knowledgable, there to help you get your work done, not to mention warm and friendly.  They indulged my questions, and even moved the telescopes around so I could take the best photospheres and movies.

Many people here have told me that working at LCO is like being part of a family, and it's absolutely true.  What a place to do science!


Wednesday, August 5, 2015

Not-Observing

In all of my previous posts, I've been observing. (Although in my last post I was observing at Gemini North, not Las Campanas Observatory.) On this run at LCO, I am doing a lot of not-observing. I arrived on Monday to a partly cloudy sky, and got to watch my office mate Serge Dieterich get a few hours of observations on the Baade telescope with FIRE. I also got to chat with the FIRE instrument PI, Rob Simcoe, which was pretty cool; he was making some upgrades to the computers system running FIRE to try to make the read-out time faster. But unfortunately, the decent weather did not last, and Serge lost much of the second half of the night. Conditions have not improved.

Last night was my first of two nights on the MIKE spectrograph, and instrument I've written about before. I'm here with Alex Ji, a graduate student at MIT working with another Las Campanas Belle, Anna Frebel. (Alex is on Twitter, @alexanderpji, you should follow him!) The plan was to split four MIKE nights, with my targets getting priority the first two nights, and Alex and Anna's targets getting priority the second two nights. This is a great partnership, because (in theory) it spreads out the weather risk a bit, and I got a chance to give Alex some lessons on using MIKE before he is by himself for the last two nights (when I'm going home). Alex is super enthusiastic, and we came up on Tuesday afternoon and did most of the calibration images needed for both our data reductions for all four nights.

Alex putting the diffuser in so we can take milky flat calibration frames. Photo credit: Cindy Hunt Benson.
 We arrived after dinner on Tuesday ready to collect photons. The weather had other plans, though.

LCO on Tuesday afternoon. Looks great!
Alex, before we walked up to the Magellans on Tuesday evening. Does not look great.


Above is an all-sky camera time lapse of last night. You can see a few sucker holes at the beginning of the night, and even the Milky Way through the clouds. But then it just gets worse...and worse...and worse. You can't even see the nearly-full moon rise near the middle of the night. Boo.

Tonight is even less promising. Luckily it isn't raining or snowing, but the clouds are certainly thicker and the wind is certainly higher. Looking at the satellite imagery,



makes it seem like we might see some clear-ish sky by the end of the night, but we'll have to wait and see. The LCO staff are not so optimistic -- they covered the instruments inside the dome, as well as several other electronics, with plastic covers, in preparation for precipitation.

Non-observing is part of being an observer, particularly a "classical" (not queue; you have to come do the observations in person yourself) and "ground-based" observer. Luckily for me, LCO is a lovely place to hang out and work and chat with interesting people.
Astronomers eating! Clockwise from back left: Alex Ji, Serge Dieterich, me, Andrew Newman,
Gwen Rudie, Cindy Hunt Benson. Photo Credit: Francesco Di Mille , with Serge's phone.
We're extra lucky to have Dr. Cindy Hunt Benson visiting LCO this week. She is the social media coordinator/promoter for Carnegie Astronomy, and has been doing an AMAZING job on Twitter and Instagram and Facebook, showing off all the interesting research and discoveries related to Carnegie Astronomy. Really, you need to go look at those social media accounts to get the best picture of Carnegie Astronomy possible. You should at least check out Cindy's Pluto Plate video -- so cool! Look out for a post from Cindy on this blog soon. She had the idea to take a time lapse video of us working last night:


which is a riff of a video Anna Frebel made a few years ago. Unlike Anna, we were not-observing, but we still got a lot of work done, and had fun! Can you spot the Quadritos?

Friday, July 24, 2015

Happy Birthday Vera Rubin!

My friend Ramin Skibba wrote a great blog post about Carnegie astronomer and dark matter pioneer Vera Rubin. Check it out!


Monday, July 20, 2015

A Brief History of Stellar Women Bonus Material

GEEK OUT. The wonderful Dr. Cynthia Hunt, an astronomer and social media guru for Carnegie Astronomy and re-re-discoverer of Pluto, saw a of Cecilia Payne's thesis at the Huntington Library last week and got a couple of quick photos. So cool!




A Brief History of Stellar Women

Tonight I'm observing at a different big telescope, Gemini North at Mauna Kea Observatory, Hawaii. But I wanted to share a great Explainer post by Dr. Amanda Bauer, a PhD Astronomer and Outreach Officer at the Australian Astronomical Observatory, that discusses spectroscopy. She was named one of Australia's "Top 5 Under 40” science researchers and communicators in March of 2015, and has written lots of blog posts about different aspects of astronomy.

This one about spectroscopy caught my interest because 1) it's my craft, too, and 2) it's one of the things in astronomy, and science in general (the basic principles come from physics and chemistry), that I explain most often/enjoy explaining most.

Here's the link. Check it out!

However, there is a bit of history missing from Dr. Bauer's post that is important. Much of what I and MANY astronomers do today for our research -- using spectra to classify and learn about stars -- is thanks to some extremely smart and dedicated women scientists. Here's a bit (er, actually, a rather long bit) of history.

In the early 1900s, the director of Harvard Observatory, Edward Pickering, had a problem similar to many scientists -- too much data and too little time or resources to analyze and understand it all. Pickering wanted to continue the work of astrophotography pioneer Henry Draper, whose great ambition it was to catalog the entire night sky with images and spectra. Unfortunately, Draper died at 45 before he was able to fulfill this ambition, but his wife Anna Mary Palmer donated money to the newly-founded Harvard College Observatory to fund the completion of this monumental survey. Imagine trying to



that could be photographed in the night sky!

So, why would Pickering hire women to help, in a time when women's work was valued even less than they are today? He could pay them less -- 25-35 cents an hour of work six days a week, seven hours a day, below what they would make in clerical work. Thus, Pickering could hire more women workers for the same price as half the number of men, and get more stars classified more quickly. The story also goes that at one point, Pickering became frustrated with his male assistant(s) and declared his maid could do a better job! I guess that was meant to be derogatory towards women, but turns out it was true --Pickering hired his maid at the time, Williamina Fleming, who went on to become the Curator of Astronomical Photographs, the first corporate appointment of a woman at Harvard ever.

Harvard Computers, 1892. Maury third from left, with magnifying glass. Flemming standing at center.

Fleming was responsible for cataloging, indexing, examining, and caring for all of the photographic plates in the Harvard catalog, as well as directing about a dozen other women "Harvard Computers". She examined over 10,000 stars (WHOA) and developed classification system for the stars from A to Q, based on how much hydrogen they showed in their spectra. In 1890 Pickering published the first Henry Draper Catalog.

Around this time, Antonia Maury, the niece of Henry Draper himself, was hired as a Computer. She had studied at the all-women's Vassar College under the first American women to work as a professional astronomer, Maria Mitchell. (Connection: I did my first undergraduate NSF REU at the Maria Mitchell Observatory!) She developed her own classification system for the tens of thousands of spectra, more complex and based on differing line widths (rather than just the presence or absence of lines). Maury's line width classification system (normal 'a', hazy, 'b', sharp, 'c', with intermediate cases) was not appreciated by Pickering at the time, and she left the project for a time. Dorrit Hoffliet, one of the other Computers, noted about Maury, "She was one of the most original thinkers of all the women Pickering employed; but instead of encouraging her attempts at interpreting observations, he was only irritated by her independence and departure from assigned and expected routine." However, Danish astronomer Ejnar Hertzsprung recognized the significance of Maury's different classification when saw that c- and ac-stars were brighter than a- or b-stars. Maury's work contributed greatly to what we know now as the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram, a plot of magnitude and luminosity against temperature that is a cornerstone of stellar evolution and classification today.

Around the same time as Maury joined "Pickering's Women" (ugh, I don't like that), a woman named Annie Jump Cannon also joined. Cannon also came from one of the top colleges for women, Wellesley College, and had studied under another female pioneer in science, Sarah Frances Whiting. Cannon took time off after Wellesley, during which she was stricken with scarlet fever and lost nearly all of her hearing. She returned to school at Radcliffe, near Harvard, and was hired by Pickering as his assistant. Cannon was able to refine the classification systems of Fleming and Maury, reducing the number of categories and rearranging them by temperature, leaving us with the famous OBAFGKM; she also included numbers 1-10 within each category as a finer distinction. Cannon's system was adopted as the standard in 1910 by the International Astronomical Union, and today with only minor changes it is known as the Harvard Spectral Classification.

Today, the American Astronomical Association has an Annie Jump Cannon Award for "outstanding research and promise for future research by a postdoctoral woman researcher." Two of the modern day women astronomers highlighted on this blog have won it -- Alycia Weinberger and Anna Frebel. How inspiring! I hope in the future more Las Campanas Belles will be AJC Award recipients.

Annie Jump Cannon, 1922

A few years before Cannon joined the Harvard Computers, another Radcliffe College alum also started volunteering at Harvard Observatory, working seven years for no pay. Henrietta Swan Leavitt, who also lost her hearing, was a classifier who was specifically tasked with studying "variable stars", whose luminosity (brightness) varied over time. During her career Leavitt discovered over 1200 variable stars, half of *all* known variable stars at the time of her death (WHOA). While studying stars in the Magellanic Clouds, Leavitt noted that a few of the variables showed a pattern -- brighter ones appeared to have longer periods of variation. She determined that these "Cepheid variables" had bright-dim cycle periods that were inversely proportional to their magnitude. By assuming that all the Cepheids within each Magellanic Cloud were about the same distance away, such that their intrinsic brightness could be deduced from their apparent brightness (which depends on distance, and was measured from the photographic plates), Leavitt derived one of the most fundamental relations in astronomy, the period-luminosity relationship. This makes Cepheid variables the first "standard candle" in astronomy, a "rung' on the distance ladder allowing astronomers to measure distances to galaxies too remote for more local measurements of distance (stellar parallax). The later discovery by Edwin Hubble that the universe is expanding was made possible by Leavitt's groundbreaking research. Hubble himself said that Leavitt deserved a Nobel Prize, but she died before her nomination could be considered.

Henrietta Swan Leavitt, not sure what year

Love this workup of an American Girl Doll to resemble Henrietta Swan Leavitt!
A few decades after the Harvard Computers got started, Cecilia Payne-Gaposchkin continued the groundbreaking work in her pursuit of a doctorate at Radcliffe College in his new graduate program in astronomy. She was the first person (let alone woman) to do so! This was made possible by a fellowship to encourage women to study at Harvard Observatory, granted by the then-Director Harlow Shapley. In the time period since the Harvard Computers started classifying star, the science of astrophysics had been born -- the lines in stellar spectra were connected to the same lines observed when different chemical elements on Earth were heated and made to emit light. When Payne arrived at Harvard, some elements like calcium and iron had been identified in stars, since they were the most prominent lines, and it was assumed these were major components stellar composition. Payne inherited Cannon's classification system, thought to be based on stellar temperature. Payne saw the connection between the atomic physics causing spectral lines and the different (high) temperatures in stellar atmospheres. Indian physicist M.N. Saha had recently demonstrated how the ionization of atoms (causing spectral lines) was related to the temperature and pressure in stars. Payne showed that the many differences in the lines of stellar spectra were due in large part to the different atomic ionization states, and hence different temperatures, and *not* to different *amounts* of elements. This seems like a subtle distinction, but it is fundamental and crucial to our understanding of the composition of anything that is not on our planet (and many things that are!). Through her work, Payne discovered that the Sun and other stars are mostly made of hydrogen and helium, not heavier elements, which account for less than 2% of the mass of most stars.

Cecilia Payne-Gaposchkin, not sure what year

Unfortunately, unsurprisingly, Payne's work was considered "clearly impossible" by male professors at the time, and in her thesis, "Stellar Atmospheres, A Contribution to the Observational Study of High Temperature in the Reversing Layers of Stars," she included the statement, that the calculated abundances of hydrogen and helium were "almost certainly not real" to protect her career. Though Princeton Professor Henry Norris Russell did not believe Payne's conclusions at first, he later changed his mind after having derived the same result and publishing it, acknowledging Payne's previous work only briefly in his paper. Russell is still often given credit for this monumental discovery. According to also-famous astronomers Otto Struve and Velta Zeberg, Payne-Gaposchkin's thesis was "undoubtedly the most brilliant Ph.D. thesis ever written in astronomy."

So, there you have it. Spectroscopy as we use it today as astronomers is in large part thanks to the contributions of these, and many more, women who worked passionately, for little or no pay, and were not discouraged by the sexism and discrimination challenges they faced. I find their stories remarkable, and am so thankful for their intrepid character and curious, persistent, brilliant minds.


Resources used to compose this summary:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvard_Computers#cite_note-1

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annie_Jump_Cannon

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henrietta_Swan_Leavitt#cite_note-famousscientists.org-1

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cecilia_Payne-Gaposchkin

https://vcencyclopedia.vassar.edu/alumni/antonia-maury.html

http://simostronomy.blogspot.com/2010/06/pickerings-women.html

www.amnh.org/education/resources/rfl/web/essaybooks/cosmic/p_payne.html